Thanks to the Metropolitan Opera’s Live in HD production earlier this year, Jonas Kaufmann’s exemplary performance in the title role set a standard so high that any other attempts to personify Goethe’s tragic poet would seem to be as doomed as Werther himself. That this was not the case is a tribute to the musical and dramatic strength of Massenet and of Shanul Sharma, who, according to the director Suzanne Chaundy’s program note, “stepped in to take up the challenge of this incredibly demanding role at short notice”.
Sharma’s performance was convincing proof that difference can be an asset by illuminating different qualities in the role.....Sharma’s ambition to sing leading roles from bel canto repertoire seem to be a realistic goal....His portrayal of ardent poetic sensibility, drawn to the charms of nature, the innocence of children and Charlotte’s empathetic warmth, was well projected and engaged the sympathies of the audience.
Jodie Hutchinson, Classicmelbourne.com.au, 'Werther' Lyric Opera of Melbourne Oct 2014